Ball Screws vs. Lead Screws: Efficiency, Applications, and Comparisons

All About Ball Screws

What Are Ball Screws?

What Are Ball Screws?

The ball screw, like lead screws, converts rotary motion from rotary to linear. This ball screw mechanism consists of threaded shafts & a ball nut. The latter device rides on the screw, which is supported by a series of ball bearings.

The latter device rides on the screw, which is supported by a series of ball bearings that provides a rolling surface rather than the sliding surface of a lead screw. The balls, part of the ball screws assemblies, roll between the nut & the shaft. This ball screw lead ensures efficient movement.

Because there are no sliding motions, ball screws move more efficiently than lead screws. This is their great advantage. The efficiency of the ballscrew is relatively constant and is generally better than 90%.

Ballscrews, often referred to as ball lead screw, are the first choices for linear-motion applications because the use of recirculating ball bearings provides high efficiency, loads capacities, & positioning accuracy.

In addition, ballscrews typically provide the same or better load capacity than leadscrews and are, therefore, betters choices when load requirements exceed leadscrew capabilities. One drawback of ballscrews is that they require a high level of lubrication.

Ballscrews should always be properly lubricated with the proper formulation to prevent corrosion, reduce friction, ensure efficient operation, and extend operating life. Backlash, a bit of play between several mechanical components, can be eliminated with preloading.

Some ball screw nuts and terms, such as circuit, turn, lead, ball screw pitch, and start, are widely used – and misused – terms that determine various aspects of a ball screw assembly. Although the terms are related, each has a unique meaning and significance for ball-screw design and performance.

Lead and pitch are related but have different specifications. Lead refers to the linear distances traveled for each complete turn of the screw, while pitches are the distance between the screw threads.

This term is often used interchangeably, & for a single-start screw, the lead and pitch are equal. However, lead & pitch are not equaled for screws with multiples starts.

Ballscrews, showcasing different arch window types, are typically available in medium leads, although hi-helix products do exist.

Considering the geometry of the screw assembly, it makes sense that as the lead of the screw becomes larger, the number of tracks inside the balls nut becomes smaller, so fewer balls carry the load.

While larger lead screw offers longer travels per revolution & higher speeds, their ability to provide higher load capacities is compromised.

In theory, the number of balls track could be increased by making the ball nut longers, but manufacturing constraints & limitations on ball nut length make this an impractical solution.

When the balls, part of the recirculating ball screw, are returned by an inner channel or outer tube, the recirculating balls may cross multiple threads, so there may be multiple balls turns in a circuit. That is, the balls make several revolutions around the screw shaft before being recirculated.

Multi-starts ball screw assemblies typically use the internal channel method of recirculation pictured.  These can be designed for multiples circuits by incorporating more than one internal recirculations channel into the nut body.

Ball Screws:

Ball Screws

Ball screws assemblies are the right products for applications that have a high cycle and constant speed and are able to operate with higher axial loads than lead screw nuts.

They are similar to recirculating ball bearings in that they use the same rolling properties as ball bearings when converting motion.

These ball screws are rolled inside special grooves that cut into the screw’s helical exterior, allowing for low friction and thus a smaller motor, higher precision, and again, the ability to operate under high-cycle conditions.

Despite these advantages for some applications, ball screws have all the same disadvantages as reciprocating ball bearings.

The most notable downfalls of both ball screws and recirculating ball bearings are their reliance on oils or greases as lubricants, which require constant maintenance to avoid failures, and poor environments with dirt, dust, wood shavings, etc. can also cause problems.

Lubrications do not lend themselves well to sensitives environments such as food processing, packaging, or laboratory and medical equipment.

Because of their low friction and ability to be easily back-driven, they are not always ideal for vertical applications – where constant motor torque, and even brake mechanisms, could cause any potential for the system to collapse.

It may be necessary to eliminate. It is often a security issue. Ball screws can apply or withstand high thrusts loads with minimal internal friction. They use balls bearings to eliminate friction between the nut and the screws & can provide high levels of efficiency, load capacity, and positioning accuracy.

Ball screws from Henson Technology can be used in the most extreme environments, such as high-performance machine tools that are in high demand and in very delicate and sensitive applications, including medical equipment.

Offering excellent reliability and reliable performance, our ball screws consistently perform the way they are expected. The materials uses are of the highest quality & suited to multiple applications ensuring long life.

What Is a Lead Screw?

What Is a Lead Screw?

The lead screws, often questioned as what is rack and pinion, are sometimes referred to as a power screw or translation screw. They are used within motion controls devices to convert rotary or motion into linear movements.

Lead screws are metal threaded bars and a threaded nut that are in direct contact with the screw; This produces sliding friction in contrast to rolling friction from other alternative devices such as ball screws. The rotational motion will rotate the screw, causing the nut to move in a linear motion.

Therefore, it converts the motion from rotary to linear. They can be used for either verticals or horizontals movements and use linear glides for support where necessary. They can either be operated manually or can be mortised, depending on the application at hand.

Where the screw itself is usually made of stainless steel, the nut can be of different materials depending on what is better for the application. Heavy-duty applications will require metal nuts, while other applications may require plastic ones.

Lead Screw:

Lead Screw

The Lead screws, also knowns as power screws are used in motion control to convert movements into linear motion. They are metal rods with a thread similar to a conventional screw. Lead screws rotate, causing the nut to move along with the screw in a linear motion.

Often, the lead screws themselves are made in the rolling process, & nuts are usually made from an injection molded or machined polymers.

These simple production methods allow for easy customization of parts, which enables designers to efficiently implement this part into their projects, even at a low cost.

They are also capable of heavy load conditions with low torque and do not back-drives, which means they are well suited for verticals applications without the added expense of a brake mechanism.

Lead Screws from Henson provide an easy and precise solution to linear motion requirements, as well as being cost-effective’s. They are accurate to 0.003in/ft, & the PTFE coating process that our lead screws are exposed to mean they have low drag torque and will last longer.

Choose from plastic nut assemblies with either anti-backlash or super-nut designs, all of which use an internally lubricated acetal. It provides excellent lubrication and wears resistance whether additional lubrication is used or not.

We can provide assemblies with high axial stiffness, zero-backlash, and minimum drag torque to reduce motor requirements; Using these products means your system will cost less, perform better, and last longer, making them great value for money.

Heesen also has bronze nuts available if you have a high enough load, providing the support needed for high-capacity loads and a good PV performance.

Lead Screw Vs Ball Screw:

Lead Screw Vs Ball Screw

Lead Screw Ball Screw
They Are Reasonable as Compared to the Latter. More expensive than lead screws.
Lead Screws Are More Efficient for Vertical Applications. Ball screws give problems when used in vertical applications.
They Are Self-Locking and Hence Do Not Require a Braking System. These require a braking system to function, which needs to be greased at regular intervals for long working hours.
These Have a Higher Friction Rate and Run at Very Hot Temperatures. They have a low friction rate and operate at very cold temperatures.
Less Efficient as It Requires Greater Torque and Motor and Drives. Considered much more efficient than lead screws as it requires less torque.
Lead Screws Do Not Contain Anything That Might Help to Get Rid of High Friction. Ball bearings are included, which help the screw keep friction under control and keep the system efficient.
Due to Its Friction Rate, Which Is High, It Is Not Suited for High Throughput or High-Speed Conditions or Those with Long Cycle Times. The ball screw is better suited in the above situations.
They Do Not Create Any Noise. They are making a lot of noise.
These Need to Be Replaced More Frequently. These work well and are generally efficient for the long haul.
These Are Cheaper. More expensive in relation to lead screws.
The Lead Screw Is Useful for Simple Transfer Applications in Which Rigidity, Precision, Etc., Do Not Matter Much. Ball screw is useful when accuracy and rigidity, and efficiency are big factors.

FAQ

What Is a Ball Screw and How Does It Work?

A ball screw is a mechanical device that converts rotary motion into linear motion using a threaded shaft and a ball nut. The ball nut, supported by ball bearings, rides on the threaded screw, providing rolling contact rather than sliding. This design reduces friction and increases efficiency.

What Are the Advantages of Using Ball Screws Over Lead Screws?

Ball screws offer higher efficiency, reduced friction, and greater precision compared to lead screws. They are suitable for applications requiring high load capacities, smooth movement, and accurate positioning. Ball screws also have a better efficiency rate, often exceeding 90%.

What Are the Disadvantages of Ball Screws?

Ball screws require regular lubrication to prevent corrosion and ensure smooth operation. They are also less ideal for environments with high levels of dirt or contaminants. Additionally, ball screws can be noisy and may require additional braking systems for vertical applications.

How Does a Lead Screw Differ from a Ball Screw?

Lead screws convert rotary motion to linear motion through sliding contact between the screw and the nut, whereas ball screws use rolling contact with ball bearings. Lead screws are typically more cost-effective and self-locking, making them suitable for vertical applications without additional braking systems. However, lead screws have higher friction and lower efficiency compared to ball screws.

When Should I Use a Lead Screw Instead of a Ball Screw?

Lead screws are ideal for applications where cost is a major factor, or where self-locking capabilities are needed for vertical movement. They are suitable for simpler transfer applications where high precision and rigidity are not critical.

What Are the Common Applications of Ball Screws?

Ball screws are commonly used in precision machinery, CNC machines, and other high-performance equipment where high accuracy, efficiency, and load capacity are required. They are also used in aerospace, medical devices, and industrial automation.

How Can I Maintain Ball Screws and Lead Screws?

Ball screws require regular lubrication to reduce friction and prevent wear. It is important to use the correct lubricant and ensure it is applied consistently. Lead screws also benefit from regular maintenance, including lubrication, to reduce friction and wear. Both types of screws should be inspected periodically for signs of damage or wear.

Can Ball Screws and Lead Screws Be Used Interchangeably?

While both ball screws and lead screws convert rotary motion to linear motion, they are not always interchangeable. The choice depends on factors such as efficiency, load capacity, precision requirements, and cost. Ball screws are preferred for high-precision and high-load applications, while lead screws are suitable for more cost-sensitive or simpler applications.

What Is the Difference Between Lead and Pitch in Ball Screws?

In ball screws, the lead is the distance the screw travels linearly for each complete turn of the screw. Pitch, on the other hand, refers to the distance between adjacent threads on the screw. For single-start screws, lead and pitch are equal, but they differ in multi-start screws where the lead is multiplied by the number of starts.

How Do I Choose Between Ball Screws and Lead Screws for My Application?

Consider factors such as efficiency, load capacity, precision, cost, and environmental conditions. Ball screws are better for high-efficiency and precision applications, while lead screws are more cost-effective and suitable for less demanding applications. Evaluate your specific needs and constraints to make the best choice.

Table of Contents

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

/* */
Scroll to Top